An honest comparison
Yeah, there are other
puzzle companies.
Here’s the breakdown.
They’re good at what they do. We’re good at something different. A puzzle made from your own idea, from a picture in your head or a photo on your phone, versus one really nice puzzle someone else designed.
Who else is in the market,
and what they’re great at.
Premium pre-designed
MagicPuzzle Company
Beautiful curated artwork on high-quality boards. Fantastic for visual surprise and gifting. No customization, no subscription, and you frame it or recycle it after assembly.
Where they win:
Visual curation, gifting, accessibility. $35 to $55 per puzzle. No commitment.
Wooden heirloom
Liberty Puzzles
Handcrafted wooden puzzles with whimsy pieces, American-made. Genuinely beautiful objects. Expensive by design at $100 to $300+ per puzzle, one-time purchase, no display system.
Where they win:
Craftsmanship, uniqueness, heirloom feel. If you want one perfect object, this is it.
Design-led, affordable
Bgraamiens
Great for design-lovers on a budget. Clean geometric and gradient art, solid print quality. No subscription cadence, no display system, no customization - buy one at a time.
Where they win:
Price point, design aesthetic, variety. $20 to $30. Strong Amazon presence.
Side by side.
Every feature that matters.
| Feature | Puzzably | MagicPuzzle | Liberty Puzzles | Bgraamiens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Puzzle image | Your own idea | Pre-designed (curated) | Pre-designed (curated) | Pre-designed (geometric) |
| AI generation | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
| Upload your photo | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
| Piece count | 500 | 100 to 1000 | 23 to 650 (wood) | 500 to 1000 |
| Material | Premium grey-core board | Premium board | American cherry wood | Standard board |
| Matte lamination | ✓ | Varies | ✗ | ✗ |
| Price | $64.99 one-off (custom) | $35 to $55 each | $100 to $300+ each | $20 to $30 each |
| Subscription required | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
| Ships within | 7 to 14 business days | Varies | 2 to 4 weeks | Varies |
Prices approximate as of June 2026. MagicPuzzle and Bgraamiens sell on Amazon and direct. Liberty sells direct only. Puzzably is direct-only.
The honest take.
Where each brand wins.
Where they beat us
Liberty makes a better object.
A Liberty puzzle is genuinely more beautiful as a physical artifact. Handcut wood, whimsy pieces, heirloom quality. If you want one perfect puzzle and you are willing to pay $200 for it, buy a Liberty. We are not competing on craftsmanship.
Where we are different
The image comes from you, not from a catalog.
Every other puzzle brand starts with art they chose. We start with an idea you describe. Text to image, photo to puzzle, or a hybrid. The result is something only you could have ordered.
Where MagicPuzzle wins
Surprise and curation.
Their curation is genuinely strong. If you want to be delighted rather than in control, they are excellent. We are for the person who already has a clear picture in their head, literally.
Where Bgraamiens wins
Accessible and low-commitment.
$25 and you are done. If you want to try puzzles without much investment, start there. We are the next step: when you want something that could only have come from you.
The Puzzably specs.
What you’re actually getting.
Real pieces
500
Five hundred genuine, individually die-cut pieces. Not a printed grid.
Finished size
530 x 390mm
Premium ESKA museum board with a matte, anti-glare finish.
Design options
4
Four AI designs from your idea. You pick the one that becomes your puzzle.
Design approval
Always
You approve the exact design in the studio before checkout. We print exactly that.
Shipping
Free
Free US shipping. Ships in about two weeks from approval.
Guarantee
Reprint
Arrives damaged? We reprint it free, no questions.
Ready to compare in person?
Make your
first puzzle.
Your idea. A real 500-piece custom puzzle. $64.99, shipped.
Make yours, $64.99One-off. No subscription required.